matrix wrote:I would like to add to this recent debate, as I feel I fit in the general public category that was mentioned earlier.
I came across this site while trying to find information about some of the comics that I had acquired.
I have sent Al about thirty scans for the specials section, he encouraged me to join the forum to discuss some of them, and once I had the courage took the plunge!
Since doing so I have learnt so much more about comics, Artists, etc. I did not really appreciate all the artwork in comics until my eyes were opened! Hard for some to understand I know, but have to agree with Rab, as at one stage I was exactly who he would like to reach out to.
My point is that you don't need piracy in order to gain knowledge about the history of comics. Like most people here, I've been a collector all my life and any knowledge I've gained has come from books on comics, blogs and forums like these, and by buying the old comics themselves.
The pro-piracy opinion seems to suggest that without illegal CDs and downloads, future generations will be ignorant of comics history. That's clearly
not the case, otherwise none of us would know about the comics that existed before
our time. If anything, it's now easier than it's ever been to learn about the history of comics, thanks to interactive forums and suchlike.
Publishers tend to turn a blind eye to the odd page or three being used to illustrate an online article about comics, but making entire runs of comics available on CD or for download is just taking the mickey. No one needs every issue of, for example, TV Comic on an illegal CD to discover what an enjoyable comic it was. A select few issues from various years would do that. Buy the back issues you can afford, like the rest of us did. They won't crumble to dust in 50 years like some think they will. (Unless they're stored in the wrong conditions.) And if you do find comics are aging too fast, there's no law against scanning and storing files for your own reading pleasure.
If you're new to comics history, Paul Gravett's superb book
Great British Comics gives a good overview of UK comics history and is well illustrated. It's available from as little as a tenner in new condition at present:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Great-British-C ... 137&sr=8-1
A few other books on the history of British comics:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/British-Comics- ... 927&sr=8-1
http://www.amazon.co.uk/History-Girls- ... 010&sr=1-1
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Haunt-Fears-Str ... 132&sr=1-3
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Art-History-Dan ... 046&sr=1-1
http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-History-Be ... gy_b_img_b
Hope that helps.